Product Backlog Prioritization: Stop Pretending Everything is High Priority

Open your backlog right now. Count how many "high priority" items you have.

More than five? You're lying to yourself. More than ten? You're lying to your team. More than twenty? Your backlog is a wishlist in a trench coat pretending to be a strategy.

The Priority Inflation Crisis

Here's a real conversation I had last week:

Stakeholder: "This needs to be high priority." Me: "What should we deprioritize to fit it in?" Stakeholder: "Nothing. Everything is high priority." Me: "That's not how reality works." Stakeholder: "But these are all critical business needs!"

Spoiler alert: They weren't.

The Truth About High Priority

If everything is high priority:

  • Nothing is high priority
  • Your team doesn't know what to work on
  • You're burning people out
  • You're shipping half-baked features
  • You've failed at your job as a Product Owner

Yeah, I said it.

Why We Lie About Priority

  1. Fear of Saying No "If I don't mark it high priority, it'll never get done!" Congratulations, you've created a self-fulfilling prophecy.

  2. Politics Over Product "But the CEO mentioned this in a meeting!" Cool. Did they mention which other feature should be delayed?

  3. Lack of Strategy "We need to stay competitive!" With what? Against whom? By when? For which users?

  4. Avoidance of Hard Choices "We'll figure it out as we go." That's not agile, that's chaos with a methodology.

Real Prioritization Isn't About Frameworks

Yes, I know about:

  • MoSCoW method
  • RICE scoring
  • Value vs Effort
  • Weighted shortest job first
  • Impact mapping
  • Story mapping
  • [Insert your fancy framework here]

None of them matter if you can't have honest conversations about trade-offs.

How to Actually Prioritize

1. Define "High Priority"

High priority means:

  • We'll drop other work to do this
  • We're willing to delay other features
  • We can explain why this can't wait
  • We have data to back up the urgency

If you can't say all of these, it's not high priority.

2. Create Priority Levels That Mean Something

Bad Priority Levels:

- Critical
- High
- Medium
- Low

Good Priority Levels:

- Fixing What's Broken (Current sprint)
- Making Money (Next sprint)
- Saving Money (This quarter)
- Everything Else (When we can)

3. Set Priority Limits

Rules that work:

  • Max 3 high priority items per sprint
  • Max 5 high priority items in backlog
  • One priority decrease for each priority increase
  • Monthly priority reset meetings

4. Make Trade-offs Visible

When someone says "make it high priority," show them this:

Current High Priority Items:
1. Payment system upgrade
2. GDPR compliance updates
3. Cart abandonment fix

To add your feature as high priority, which one should we delay?

Make them choose.

How to Say No (Without Saying No)

Bad Responses:

  • "We'll try to fit it in"
  • "It's in the backlog"
  • "Maybe next sprint"

Good Responses:

"Here are our current high priority items and their business impact:
1. Payment system: $50k/day in processing
2. GDPR: Legal requirement, deadline March 1
3. Cart abandonment: Losing $30k/week

Which one should we postpone for your feature?"

The Cost of Priority Inflation

  1. Team Burnout

    • Everything is urgent
    • No clear focus
    • Constant context switching
    • Weekend work becomes normal

  2. Quality Suffers

    • Rushed implementations
    • Skipped testing
    • Technical debt
    • Production issues

  3. Lost Trust

    • Team stops believing priorities
    • Stakeholders get frustrated
    • Everyone games the system

A Real Prioritization Example

Bad Priority Setting:

Backlog:
- Add dark mode (High)
- Fix payment bugs (High)
- Update homepage (High)
- Add reports (High)
- Improve performance (High)

Good Priority Setting:

Fixing What's Broken (This Sprint):
- Fix payment bugs
  Impact: Losing $1000/day
  Urgency: Current customer pain
  Effort: 2 days

Making Money (Next Sprint):
- Add premium features
  Impact: $50k/month potential
  Urgency: Competitive gap
  Effort: 1 week

Saving Money (This Quarter):
- Automation tools
  Impact: Save 20 hrs/week
  Urgency: Medium
  Effort: 2 weeks

Everything Else:
- Dark mode
- Homepage update
- Nice-to-have features

Questions That Kill Bad Priority Requests

When someone says "make it high priority," ask:

  1. "What's the cost of not doing this?"
  2. "What data shows this is urgent?"
  3. "Which high priority item should we delay?"
  4. "How does this align with our quarterly goals?"
  5. "What happens if we do this in 3 months instead?"

The Truth About Prioritization

Your backlog isn't a democracy. It's not about making everyone happy. It's about:

  • Making hard choices
  • Saying no
  • Backing decisions with data
  • Being honest about capacity
  • Protecting your team from chaos

Stop pretending everything is high priority. Start having real conversations about trade-offs. Your team deserves better than a backlog full of lies.

Need help writing clear, properly prioritized tickets? Try Refinewise - because not everything can be high priority. No signup needed.